This is not nearly as serious as the Team Jacob vs. Team Edward debate but it is relevant in the world today. PowerPoints are used to teach students and used in the careers those students obtain after school. Team Tufte said “PowerPoint is Evil” in a Wired magazine article. Team Byrne wrote “Learning to Love PowerPoint” in the same magazine. I am Team Byrne for the fact that I see PowerPoint as a very useful tool. I learn best visually and with note taking.
Tufte made the argument that PowerPoint “elevates format over content” and needs many slides due to little information on each slide. This can result to boredom as a result of a slow and long PowerPoint presentation. Byrne on the other hand said with PowerPoint one can organize ideas, attach content, bend the program to ones needs, and then it runs by itself.
PowerPoint can be long but I believe that it can turn boring if the presenter does not present the information in a way that will keep ones attention. Tufte said that with little information on each slide more detail is needed for a better understanding of the content. The presenter of a PowerPoint is not restricted to voicing the bullets that are on a slide. PowerPoint is an outline for elaboration. Elaboration made with words or with content.
While in my Comm. and New Media class we watched a Scott McCloud lecture on TED.com where he discussed comics with the aid of a PowerPoint presentation. On the PowerPoint there were no bullets but rather visuals and pictures. His lecture was the opposite of boring and his visuals were part of his discussion and all he had to do was press a button to continue his discussion. The PowerPoint gave greater understanding to what he was saying.
Granted I do believe that PowerPoint can be too animation driven at times and drag on but used and presented cleverly and efficiently PowerPoint is very useful. A long boring PowerPoint presentation can be as boring as a long lecture with no extra content.
No comments:
Post a Comment